Authorities said William Arthur Field, 61, broke into the Mission Drive church and took the pastor’s wallet and checkbook.
Police say several pouches that hold the Catholic church’s pyxes, which are containers that hold consecrated bread of the Eucharist, were also taken.
Field allegedly entered through a window and took items from the priest’s bedroom.
Field was identified as a suspect through fingerprints.
The church was also robbed on Dec. 23.